Chuka Umunna, London’s youngest MP, has raised with ministers concerns that the government’s bursary scheme to replace Education Maintenance Allowance could be discriminatory.
The government’s own equality impact assessment into EMA’s replacement, which was published recently, says students could face discrimination under the new scheme, which it says is “open to unintended discrimination on the basis of disability; gender; ethnicity or other characteristics protected under equality law.”
The assessment says that the government is still considering whether a system of “central arbitration” should be introduced to ensure that unintended discrimination does not take place.
Mr Umunna raised the concerns about discrimination under the new system with Leader of the House Sir George Young yesterday and was promised a response from Education Secretary Michael Gove on the matter.
Under the EMA system, which is being abolished by the government, awards are made in bands according to household income and 650,000 young people benefitted, but under the new system just 12,000 stand to receive support.
A government consultation on the new system finishes on May 20, but there are doubts over whether the new system can be put in place for students to make applications and for allocations of bursary funding to be made by the start of the 2011-12 academic year in September.
Many further questions remain about the new bursary system replacing EMA, including what support schools and colleges will be given: EMA was administered by central government, but schools and colleges themselves will administer the new system. It is also unclear how the government plans to advertise and inform students of the new system and its eligibility criteria, particularly given the limited timeframe in which to do so.
Mr Umunna has tabled a series of parliamentary questions for Education Secretary Michael Gove seeking answers on these questions, including what date students will receive funding and when applications must be made by.
In December, Mr Umunna visited Lambeth College along with Shadow Education Secretary Andy Burnham MP to meet with students who benefitted from EMA; 60 per cent of students at the college received the allowance.
Commenting, Mr Umunna said:
“There are real doubts about the government’s planned replacement for EMA, both on whether it will create the potential for discrimination and on whether it will be fully up and running in time and how students will be informed of the changes and the new eligibility criteria.
“More than 60% of students at Lambeth College received EMA and it made a real difference, with lower dropping out rates and improved qualifications among those receiving the support.”